Capability-Virtue Political Judgment in the Thought of "Martha Nussbaum"
Subject Areas : Research in Theoritical Politics
Mahmoud
Alipour
1
(PH.D of Political Science, Tarbiat Modares University, Iran. )
Saiedalireza
Hosseinibeheshti
2
(Assistant Professor, Department of Political Science, Tarbiat University, Madras, Iran. )
Keywords: Nussbaum, political judgment, capability approach, normative political thought. ,
Abstract :
One of the issues raised in the late political philosophy is the revival of the linguistic concept called "political judgment". Political judgment can be considered as the expression of one's understanding and perception of a political event or situation. Based on this definition, the essence ofPolitical thingis defined based on speech, decision and judgment in political life. Historically/ conceptually, political Judgment has gone through two major Transformation. One: in the form of Platonic awe and following predetermined criteria (idea-centric), And the second in the form of devalued face of the world of politics and centralization, interpretation and benefit of man as the standard of everything (relativistic). Nussbaum's normative approach proposes a third and distinct type of judgment under the title of "virtuosity-ability". Therefore, the question arises, what is the nature of political Judgment in Nussbaum's thought, and where is the position of "ability-virtue" in it? In her view, political judgment is related to "valuable and virtuous political feelings and emotions", and on the other hand, to "capability approach" in the sense of what citizens can and should do. From this point of view, Nussbaum tries to criticize the standard-oriented and non-normative Judgment by proposing political liberalism against comprehensive liberalism. And on the other hand, she is against imposing those judgments on the political decision-making situations of citizens.
ارسطو (1385) اخلاق نیکوماخوس، ترجمه محمدحسن لطفی، تهران، طرح نو.
اسلوت، مایکل (1392) «اخلاق فضیلت»، ترجمه وحید سهرابی¬فر، هفت‌آسمان، شماره 59، صص 164-182.
برلین، آیزیا (1393) «درباب داوری سیاسی»، ترجمه عزت¬الله فولادوند، تهران، ماهی، صص 256-257.
ریتزر، جرج (1394) نظریه¬های جامعه‌شناسی در دوران معاصر، ترجمه محسن ثلاثی، تهران، علمی.
منوچهری، عباس (1398) «کارایی علم سیاست در جامعه، علمی که راه¬های خوشبختی را نشان می‌دهد»، گفت¬وگوی محمدصادق پورابراهیم اهوازی با دکتر عباس منوچهری، روزنامه ایران، شماره ۷۰۹۸.
نوسبام، مارتا (1389) ارسطو، ترجمه عزت¬الله فولادوند، تهران، طرح نو.
یونسی، مصطفی (1387) نسبت فلسفۀ سیاسی و فلسفۀ زبان افلاطون، تهران، فرهنگ صبا ورخداد نو.
Anderson, Charles w (1988) political judgment and policy analysis, public Administration Quartely. Vol 11. No 4, pp 439- 462.
Arendt, Hannah (1992) Lectures on Kant's political philosophy, Edited and with a interpretive essay by Ronald beiner, the university of Chicago xi.
------------------ (2003) Responsibility and Judgment, Edited and with an Introduction by Jerome kohn, Schocken Books, New york: x.
------------------(1990) “Philosophy and Politics, ” Social Research 57, no. 1.
Azmanova, albena (2012) The Scandal of Reason: A Critical Theory of Political Judgment (New Directions in Critical Theory). Columbia University Press. In preface.
Beiner, Ronald (1983) political Judgment, Routledge. 3.
---------------- (1992) What's The Matter With Liberalism?, University of California Press. p3.
Bourke, Richard and Raymond Geuss (2009) Political Judgment: Essays for John Dunn, editor: Cambridge university press.
Ferguson, Kennan (1999) The Politics of Judgment: Aesthetics, Identity, and Political Theory, Lexington books, Rowman and littlefield.
Ferrara, alessandro (2007) political cosmopolitanism and judgment, European Journal of Social Theory, Vol 10, Issue 1.
Flyvbjerg, Bent (2004) Phronetic Planning Research: Theoretical and Methodological Reflections Planning Theory and Practice, Vol. 5, No. 3, pp 283–306.
Gadamer, H. - G. (2004) Truth and Method, trans. J. Weinsheimer and D. G. Marshall. London.
Green. O. H. (1990) Emotions, A Philosophical Theory, Springer: Dordrecht.
Gustavo Ortiz Millán (2016) Nussbaum on the cognitive nature of emotions, Manuscrito 39 (2), pp 119- 131 (2016).
Habermas, J. (1995) “Reconciliation Through the Public Use of Reason: Remarks on John Rawls’s. p 124.
Haddock, bruce (2005) contingency and judgment in oakshotts political thought, European Journal of Political Theory, vol4, issue 1.
Haflidson, Ron (2014) Saint Augustine on the role of the Holy Spirit in judgment, thesis for postgraduate degree (e. g. PhD, MPhil, DClinPsychol) at the University of Edinburgh. p3.
Michel de Montaigne (1991) “The essays of Michel de Montaigne”, Lane, Allen.
Nussbaum, Martha (1999) Virtue Ethics: The Misleading Category, ARETÍ revista de filosofía, Vol. XI, Nllli 1-2, 1999, pp 533- 571.
----------------------- (2001) Upheavals of Thought, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
----------------------- (2003) Capabilities as Fundamental Entitlemnts: sen and Social Justice, Feminist Economics, 9: 2-3, pp 33-59.
------------------------ (2004) Emotions as Judgment of Value and Importance, In Thinking about Feeling, Contemporary Philosophers on Emotions edited by Robert C. Solomon, Oxford university press.
------------------------ (2011) creating capabilities, Harvard university press.
------------------------ (2013) Political Emotions: Why Love Matters for Justice, Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press, 2.
Palmer, John (2017) Contradiction and Aporia in Early Greek Philosophy, cited in: the aporetic tradition in ancient philosophy, Cambridge University Press: 9.
Perri, Six(2011) Explaining Political Judgement, Cambridge University Press.
Pico, dela mirondela (1956) On human Dignity, translated by Robert caponigri, regnery publishing Washington: 5.
Rawls, John (1995) political liberalism, Columbia university press.
Roberts, Robert C. (1999) Emotions as Judgments in Philosophy and Phenomenological Research Vol. 59, No. 3 (Sep. , 1999), pp 793- 798.
Ruderman, Richard (1997) Aristotlea and Recovery of Political Judgment, American Political Science Reviwe, Vol 91, No. 2, pp 409- 420.
Sorabji, Richard (2002) Emotion and Peace Of Mind, oxford university prees.
Steinberger P. J (1993) The concept of Political Judgment, The University of Chicago Press, ix.
Thaler, Naly (2016) Judgment, Logos, and Knowledge in Plato’s Theaetetus, Philosophy Compass (2016)11, pp 246–255.
Thompson, Dennis F (1984) Political Theory and Political Judgment, PS, vol. 17, no. 2, 1984, pp 97-193.
Watter, Miguel (2011) The people Shall be Judge: Reflective Judgment and Constituent in Knts Philosophy of Law, Political Theory, Vol 39, Issue 6.
------------------- (2011) The people Shall be Judge: Reflective Judgment and Constituent in Knts Philosophy of Law, Political Theory, Vol 39, Issue 6.
Zerilli, linda m. g (2006) The Truth And Politics, Theory & Event, Volume 9, Issue 4.